I took an informal poll and asked my sisters and mother, who love to read as much as I do, what their criteria is for a great book. Here are their answers:
- Sister #1 said she considers a book great if she can suspend disbelief and completely believe in the characters and the world in which the story takes place. (She reads a lot of Urban Fantasy, Paranormal, and Horror.)
- Sister #2 said her criteria for a good book is one that takes her on an emotional journey, where she can completely empathize with the main character(s). (She reads various sub-genres of Romance.)
- Sister #3 had a hard time articulating what makes a good book for her. She said it would be one that made her hate to put it down, one that has great writing, and makes her hate to say goodbye to the characters when the book ends. (She reads a lot of Mainstream, Women's Fiction, and Romance.)
- Sister #4 also said that the story has to be believable. A good storyline and one that has good pacing and isn't choppy in the telling of the story is important too. (She reads everything and anything that peaks her interest.)
- My mother said the story has to hold her attention, have good pacing and isn't bogged down with too many details that make me think,"all right, already." (She reads a lot of Suspense, Thrillers, Mysteries, and Romance.)
I tend to read paranormal-romance, YA & urban fantasy. I'm reading a "good" book now...probably a 4 star since it is well written and a good story... but I've been reading it for about a month because life has been busy. But I know if it were a GREAT book, that I'd make time for it. That I'd be thinking about the characters when not reading it. A GREAT book is one in which the story and characters pull me in, and refuse to let me go - even when life is busy.
ReplyDeleteWhat a wonderful way to describe a Great book - one that draws you in so that even when you're not reading it, it's still on your mind.
DeleteThere have been some books that I absolutely hated to have to put down and that I would pick back up to read even if I only had a few minutes free and only had time to read a few sentences.